Johnny's Pizzeria

Johnny's Pizzeria, located in Whippany, NJ, consistently impresses patrons with its authentically crafted pizza and warm, welcoming atmosphere. Renowned for its thin, crisp crust, customers rave about the flawless texture and balance of flavors. The buffalo chicken pie receives particular acclaim, with many asserting it to be addictive. The charm of the establishment is amplified by the presence of Nonna working the counter, enhancing the homely vibe. Regulars like Anthony Maggio ardently praise the plain and vodka sauce pies, calling them "godly" and "out of this world." Whether you’re biting into their perfectly seasoned pepperoni Sicilian pizza, as Patrick Postiglione recommends, or relishing a grandma pie, the quality remains consistently high. With friendly service, as highlighted by Kelly Smith and Andrew T, the experience at Johnny's transcends mere dining—it’s about creating lasting memories. For pizza enthusiasts seeking an exceptional meal or a fulfilling sandwich, Johnny’s Pizzeria is a must-visit. Each visit is a reminder of what pizza should taste like, and I can hardly wait to return for another slice.